5/19/2008

Student journalists ready for mainstream media

Liberals and conservatives differ on freedom of the press and speech. Conservatives call a newspaper story that presents both sides of an issue "fair and balanced." Liberals call the same newspaper story "biased."

Some of the writers at the Wayzata High School newspaper, the Trojan Tribune, are already practicing "activist journalism," whereby advancing an agenda takes precedence over informing their readers. In other words, they're ready for the mainstream media.

For example, the op-ed article, "Sex Ed is not educational," stated:
Comprehensive sex education is the only way to see a change in teen behavior. These programs are able to teach teens not only about abstinence, but focus on the fact that teens are already having sex. They state the risk of sexual intercourse like pregnancy and STI's, but also provide information on contraceptives and STI's. Clearly there is no other program that teens could benefit more from. The other option, an abstinence-only program, has been proven to distribute false information. Now why would the government want to fund a sex education program that teaches false information?

The writer alleges that abstinence-only programs have been "proven to distribute false information" — without stating any evidence. This amounts to the liberal's favorite tactic of ad hominem attack on the individual, while avoiding directly addressing the pros and cons of their position. It's a lazy approach. Yes, this is an opinion piece, but substantive evidence of the claim would strengthen the case.

Another article from the Trojan Tribune, "Biased Social Studies textbooks?" is more subtle, but is a prime example of how liberals' preference for censorship over free speech belies their fear of true debate. The article reported without challenge on a slanted Associated Press report of "conservative bias" in social studies textbooks:
New Jersey high-school senior, Matthew LaClair, recently accused his Social Studies textbook of having biased viewpoints.

LaClair said that his AP Government textbook, "American Government," by James Wilson and John Dilulio, showed conservative views on the political topics discussed in the popular textbook. "I just realized from my own knowledge that some of this stuff in the book is just plain wrong,” said LaClair in an interview with Nancy Zuckerbrod of the Associated Press. The topics included global warming, separation of church and state, and praying at school. An excerpt from the textbook said, "Science doesn’t know whether we are experiencing a dangerous level of global warming or how bad the greenhouse effect is, if it exists at all." The latest edition of the textbook, published last year, now says, "Science doesn’t know how bad the greenhouse effect is."

With this "debate is over" approach to newsgathering, the mainstream media will be doing all of the "critical thinking" for our children — if we let them.

5/07/2008

House votes unanimously to leave NCLB behind

On Monday, April 28, the Minnesota House of Representatives voted 128-0 (see Journal page 10824) in favor of an amendment to the omnibus education bill, SF 3001/HF 3316, that would ask the U.S. Secretary of Education to relieve the state of Minnesota from the federal No Child Left Behind Act's (NCLB) educational assessment and accountability provisions, while continuing to provide federal funding under the act.

As EdWatch points out, NCLB is costing school districts more than they are receiving, while de facto putting the federal government in charge of local and state educational policy. Further, academic achievement, especially for poor and minority students is not improving under NCLB.

Unfortunately, reported EdWatch in an e-mail to supporters, the Senate and Governor oppose this amendment, so only constituent pressure will increase its chances of surviving in the conference committee report. Even if the measure passes and is signed into law, the Bush administration has resisted similar past requests by the states.

The apparent long odds for the withdrawal from the federal intrusion into the states' education mandate reminds me of that surprisingly engaging legislative and moral saga, Amazing Grace. The film follows the lifelong quest of William Wilberforce to abolish the slave trade in England. Beginning in 1791, Wilberforce brought the same resolution to Parliament year after year, to defeat after defeat, until finally the bill passed in 1807.

Although slavery is not at stake in this case, freedom is. Please contact your state House member, state Senator, and Governor Pawlenty and urge them to support state control of K-12 education.