12/14/2007

Fred Thompson on education policy

One of the good things about campaign season is that, if you look hard enough, you can uncover substantive debate on issues you care about.

Presidential candidate Fred Thompson's white paper on education caught my eye. It sums up several points of the conservative position on education reform.

The Tenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution leaves education to the states, but thanks to President Lyndon Johnson's Elementary and Secondary Education Act of 1965, the establishment of the federal Department of Education by President Jimmy Carter, and of course the Sen. Edward Kennedy/George W. Bush No Child Left Behind Act, federal bureaucrats have reduced local school boards to choosing colors for the carpet and conducting excess levy referenda to fund teacher contracts and federal mandates.

Fred Thompson would change the course of federal intervention in education. It would be like turning an ocean liner to be sure, but as presidents Johnson, Carter, and Geroge W. Bush have shown, the White House can have a profound effect on the schoolhouse for decades. Thompson's position recognizes practical and political realities of today's federal education system by not proposing an immediate abolition of the U.S. Department of Education (although we favor it), instead proposing a course correction in the form of block grants with accountability to replace today's increasingly onerous federal micromanagement of education.

From Thompson's education white paper:
State and local governments are closest to the parents, the kids, and the schools. They are best situated to implement changes and innovations that result in better educated children. A new, simplified, federal education block grant program with objective testing standards would bring us closer to reaching the shared goal of improving our schools, while preserving local control. We must begin by returning to our core principles of more parental control and choice, higher standards, and greater accountability as described below:

Empowering Parents, Teachers, and Local School Boards

  • Give parents the ability to choose the best setting situation to meet the needs of their children--whether in a public, private, religious, home or charter school setting.

  • Empower parents and provide choices through vouchers and tax credits.

  • Help educators and school boards by removing federal bureaucratic red-tape and paperwork.

Promoting Higher Standards for Academic Excellence

  • Give states greater flexibility to better measure individual student progress by encouraging the development of individualized state education plans.

  • Remove federal mandates that penalize states for adhering to higher academic standards.

  • Condition education funding on states setting objective, measurable test standards.

  • Encourage students to pursue careers in science, technology, engineering and math.

Ensuring Accountability within America's Education System

  • Measure individual student progress and provide assistance to those who need it.

  • Challenge America's children to succeed in the competitive global economy by offering advanced course-work and more focused educational opportunities.

  • Incentivize teachers who help close the achievement gap by rewarding them for serving in the most challenging schools.

  • Promote transparency to assess academic performance and share innovations in education.

12/06/2007

Texas pulls funding from Everyday Mathematics curriculum

The State of Texas has pulled its funding for the third grade unit of the integrated math curriculum Everyday Mathematics (the University of Chicago School Mathematics Program, a.k.a. "Chicago Math," or just "fuzzy math"). The state board of education charged that the program leaves Texas public school graduates "unprepared" for college math.

As The New York Sun newspaper reported, "While supporters of Everyday Math applaud it and other so-called progressive programs for their emphasis on problem-solving and group work, opponents charge that the best way to teach math is still through rote memorization of facts, calling anything else 'fuzzy math.' A recent entry by the federal Department of Education into the debate cleared up little, judging Everyday Math more effective than some more traditional programs but calling its impact still just 'potentially' positive."

Texas public schools can still receive funding for the other grade units in the grades 1-5 series, or even use local funding to purchase the third grade Everyday Math unit. But some anticipate that most Texas schools will choose another curriculum rather than spend the extra money, or fill in with another curriculum just for the third grade.

According to The New York Sun, the Texas decision has national implications:
Since Texas is one of the country's largest buyers of educational textbooks, the advocates said its decision could force textbook publishers and school districts to rethink their position in the battle.

"What happens in Texas has ramifications for the whole country," a longtime Texas activist for traditional curricula, Donna Garner, said. "It's a huge movement."

Merry Christmas from Scholar the Owl

Thanks to all of you who read Scholar's Notebook now and then, subscribe to our RSS feed, or just find us by entering "integrated math" into Google. I have gone from continual blogging during the Profile of Learning repeal battle with my friends at EdWatch (who are still doing yeoman's work for freedom, by the way), to joining Cheri Pierson Yecke in the academic standards battle, to raising awareness about integrated math. Now other projects and raising teenage children has taken more of my time, but I am no less committed to knowledge-based curricula and local control of education than I was on day 1.

Through it all, I have learned a lot from many of you smart, good people who are so selflessly dedicated to preserving this country's founding principles of freedom. You are the bedrock of our nation.

Although my posts have been infrequent, I will continue to blog at this location until further notice, as well as on "my other blog," North Star Liberty, and operate my old Minnesota Education Reform News web site. Keep the faith, have yourself a merry little Christmas, and have a happy 2008.

Matt Abe, a.k.a., Scholar the Owl